Goa’s double standards on Mhadei are baffling

Goa accepts water transfer from Tillari to Mhadei basin
No one seems to have read the report of the Mhadei Water Disputes Tribunal, or have simply chosen to ignore it.
No one seems to have read the report of the Mhadei Water Disputes Tribunal, or have simply chosen to ignore it.Gomantak Times

For now, the River Mhadei is front and centre in the collective imagination of Goa. The state, led by its MLAs’ fanciful thinking, has conjured up a scenario where the Mhadei runs dry, even though all evidence points in the other direction.

In Goa’s imagination, evidence is not important, scientific studies do not matter and data is irrelevant. We simply want is to keep our water and have it too.

The one thing that came through at the seven-hour House session to discuss the River Mhadei is that no one seems to have read the report of the Mhadei Water Disputes Tribunal, or have simply chosen to ignore it.

No one seems to have read the report of the Mhadei Water Disputes Tribunal, or have simply chosen to ignore it.
A guide to the 6 best scenic rides in Goa

It should have been the starting point for any meaningful discussion on the issues at hand. But sadly, that was not the case.

Instead, MLAs cutting across party lines chose to harp on three points — opposition to transfer of water out of the Mhadei basin, withdrawal of sanction granted to Karnataka’s DPRs and immediate formation of the Mhadei Water Management Authority.

The first part of the resolution — out of basin transfer — exposes Goa’s double standards. How can Goa object to out-of-basin water transfer when it openly accepts water transferred from the Tillari to the Mhadei basin via the Tillari Dam project?

No one seems to have read the report of the Mhadei Water Disputes Tribunal, or have simply chosen to ignore it.
Star-gazers in Goa are in for a celestial treat this week

If Goa MLAs had read the Tribunal report, they would have found the page which refers to the report of the Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal, which upheld the legality of trans-basin diversion of water.

Also, the Godavari Water Disputes Tribunal permitted Andhra Pradesh to transfer 80 tmc from the River Godavari to the Krishna basin.

Trans-basin transfer of water is the done thing, so to standing up and saying we object to it is not going to cut much ice, legally speaking.

Secondly, we always talk about how Karnataka and Maharashtra’s plans to divert water would destroy the environment. What about Goa’s own plans to suck water from the Mhadei?

No one seems to have read the report of the Mhadei Water Disputes Tribunal, or have simply chosen to ignore it.
Catholic nuns in Goa, living for the service of God and man

Would that not affect salinity, navigation in the Cumbarjua Canal and the environment?

Consider this. The Tribunal permitted Karnataka to collectively divert 3.9 tmc, while Maharashtra was allowed to draw 0.56 tmc. Guess how much water Goa has been permitted to draw from the Mhadei?

Roughly 34 tmc. That is 9.4 tmc that it is already extracting (two and half times more that Karnataka) and an additional 24 tmc for the 59 projects that it has in hand.

The question is how can Goa object to diversion of 4.46 tmc by Karnataka and Maharashtra combined and draw 9.4 tmc and propose projects to draw another 24 tmc while simultaneously crying hoarse about protection of the environment? If this isn’t double standards, what is?

No one seems to have read the report of the Mhadei Water Disputes Tribunal, or have simply chosen to ignore it.
GALF, a festival that survived a pandemic, makes comeback

Why is every MLA going to extreme lengths to protect the environment when the Tribunal has already accepted Goa’s stand that the environment has to be protected?

If the MLAs had read the report, they would have found the 68 pages dedicated to protection of the environment and the stringent conditions laid down for diversion of water from Kalasa and Bhandura tributaries.

It is clear from the Tribunal’s order that the needs of the environment have to be balanced with judicious utilisation of water.

Goa needs to understand this principle because the Supreme Court too is of the view that rivers are national assets and no single state can claim sole ownership of river water.

Your Gateway to Goa, India

The Gomantak Times app is the best way to stay informed on anything happening in Goa. From breaking news to the top 10 restaurants to visit, GT helps you navigate your time in Goa.

Download the Gomantak Times app on your Android or IOS device.

Related Stories

No stories found.
logo
Gomantak Times
www.gomantaktimes.com