DGP, GSPCB and Mines director face HC rap over illegal quarrying

Complaint of large-scale quarrying of Sept 14, 2020, was ignored and activity went on unabated; court seeks answers why FIR lodged on July 25, 2022
The court also questioned the role of the panchayat.
The court also questioned the role of the panchayat.

The Director General of Police, Director of Mines and Geology and Goa State Pollution Control Board found themselves in the dock over a complaint filed by Buddha Arjun Gaonkar alleging large-scale illegal quarrying in the villages of Barkatem, Mollem and Dharbandora.

Gaonkar had filed several complaints before various government departments, the first of which was on September 14, 2020. However, since no action was forthcoming Gaonkar finally approached the High Court of Bombay at Goa.

The petitioner alleged that large-scale quarrying for laterite stones was undertaken with the help of earth-moving machinery, prompting the court to immediately direct officials to visit the site and stop the work if not backed by permissions.

The court also questioned the role of the panchayat.
Two builders in Goa fight it out in court and lose

Role of PI questioned

In the afternoon on the same day, a two-member bench comprising Justices R N Laddha and M S Sonak took up the matter when the government advocate stated that no quarrying works were being undertaken at the site and admitted that no permissions had been granted. It was also brought to the notice of the court that an FIR against unknown persons was lodged on July 25, 2022.

But the court saw through the smoke screen. It asked why an FIR was lodged on July 25, 2022, when the complaint was filed in 2020. The court also sought to know why the FIR was lodged against unknown persons when the names of the perpetrators were mentioned in the complaint.

Accordingly, the court directed the DGP to inquire into the role of the PI in charge of the Collem police station, ensure that an investigation is conducted and report back to the court on August 17.

The court also questioned the role of the panchayat.
CM Pramod Sawant suggests including Konkani in court proceedings in Goa

GSPCB officials had visited the site

The High Court pointed out that the earliest complaint made to the Director General of Mines and Geology is dated September 21, 2020, and asked the department what action it had taken between the time the complaint was filed and now and file an affidavit in this respect. It also noted that if steps had been taken within a reasonable time such large-scale quarrying would not have taken place.

During the hearing, it became apparent that two officials of the Goa State Pollution Control Board had visited the site. The court wanted to know if any show-cause notice was issued and directed the GSPCB to file an affidavit on action taken.

The court also questioned the role of the panchayat.
Change-Makers: 5 NGOs in Goa that you need to know

No cognisance of complaints taken

Since the site in question falls in an eco-sensitive area declared by the Ministry of Environment and Forests, the petitioner filed a complaint before the chief secretary in March this year. The undersecretary (revenue) simply forwarded the copy of the complaint to the Collector (South Goa) for appropriate action.

Inaction by the government prompted the High Court to state that, “prima facie it appears the petitioners' complaints were simply forwarded by the officials who were required to look into the same and take immediate action. No effective actions were ever taken. Meanwhile, large-scale quarrying activity and theft of laterite stones continued unabated. Even the panchayat authorities chose not to take any action in the matter.”

The court also questioned the role of the panchayat.
Things to do in Goa during the monsoons

Your Gateway to Goa, India

The Gomantak Times app is the best way to stay informed on anything happening in Goa. From breaking news to the top 10 restaurants to visit, GT helps you navigate your time in Goa.

Download the Gomantak Times app on your Android or IOS device.

Related Stories

No stories found.
Goa News in English on Gomantak Times
www.gomantaktimes.com